Why Topping a Tree Does More Harm Than Good in Oakland County
Updated October 2026
- ISA Certified Arborist MI-4857A
- Oakland County since 2013
- Licensed and insured
- 5.0 stars from 17 Google reviews
What topping is
Topping cuts main limbs or the central leader back to stubs. Crown reduction is different: each cut returns to a suitable side branch that can continue the limb’s growth.
A proper reduction cut leaves a branch that can continue growing. A stub cut leaves a larger wound that may not close well.

What happens to a topped tree
- The tree loses a large share of its canopy at once. It can no longer make the energy it needs to recover and defend itself.
- The stubs do not seal the way a correct cut at a branch collar does. That leaves an open door for decay fungi and insects for years.
- The tree reacts to the lost leaf area by throwing up dozens of fast, weakly attached shoots called water sprouts.
- Water sprouts break off in wind more easily than the original limbs did.
- Over the following years the tree typically declines, with dead wood and weak spots at the cuts that were meant to make it safer.
What the pruning standard says
The International Society of Arboriculture advises against topping as a way to reduce height. For crown reduction, cuts should go back to suitable side branches, just beyond the branch collar. Cutting between branches leaves a stub and a large exposed wound.
If a limb has to come back, ISA’s guidance is to cut to a side branch. That branch should be at least one-third the diameter of the limb removed. Never cut to a bare stub.
What to ask for instead
- Crown thinning. This removes selected branches from inside the canopy to cut wind resistance and weight, without changing the tree’s natural outline.
- Crown reduction. This cuts back to a side branch at least one-third the diameter of the limb removed. It lowers the tree’s height or spread and keeps the structure sound.
- Deadwood removal. This takes out only dead or diseased limbs, with no cuts into healthy wood.
Crown reduction can lower the canopy while keeping the tree’s structure. A certified arborist can explain whether it is suitable for your tree.
Topped trees I see in Oakland County
I get called to previously topped trees in Waterford, Birmingham and across the county. Usually the regrowth has become hazardous, or decay has started at the old cuts. Often the homeowner paid once for the topping and now pays again, for corrective pruning or a removal. If your tree was topped years ago and now has thick, fast, upright growth at the old cuts, get a tree risk assessment.
Crown reduction →Tree removal →Declining trees →
Frequently asked questions
Is topping ever the right call for a tree near power lines?
Not on your own tree. Utility line clearance pruning looks similar from the ground, but it follows a different standard. It aims to keep wood away from the wire, and utility-trained crews do it. DTE says its crews trim trees near its lines, and that the service line from the pole to your house is the homeowner’s job. DTE warns against trimming near any line yourself and says to hire a professional. For a tree on your property that is too tall, crown reduction cuts the size without stub cuts. The ISA calls topping one of the most harmful pruning practices. Do not climb or cut near any line yourself. Call your utility first, then call me.
My tree was already topped years ago. Can it be fixed?
Not undone, but it can be corrected going forward. An arborist can thin the water sprouts, keep the best-attached ones to form a sounder structure and remove the rest. It takes several pruning cycles over a few years, not one visit. The ISA says the sprouts that follow topping are weakly attached. They can break in wind, ice and snow. The sooner the correction starts, the better. It will not restore the original form, but it lowers the failure risk the topping created. Have an arborist look at the tree before you decide. Ask for the number of the ISA certificate, and ask which branches will come off in the first visit. A plan that spreads the work over several years is a good sign.
Why do some companies still offer topping if it is against the standard?
Topping is fast and cheap, and it shows a result the same day. The cost comes later, in storm-damaged regrowth or decay. Ask anyone proposing size reduction whether the cut goes to a side branch or to a stub, and ask for their ISA certification number.
How much does crown reduction cost compared to topping?
Reduction pruning is priced on time and access, not on how the cuts are made. Topping can be priced lower because it takes less skill and less time per cut. That is part of why it persists despite the standard against it. A free on-site estimate gives you the number for your tree.
Will a topped tree eventually die?
Not always, but its life expectancy and reliability both drop. Some trees survive topping for decades, declining slowly and regrowing weak wood. Others fail within a few years once decay reaches the trunk through the stub cuts. You cannot predict which, so the safer choice is not to top the tree.
Considering size reduction on a mature tree?
I will tell you whether crown reduction, thinning or removal is the right call. I do not top trees. Estimates are free across Oakland County.